Case Details

Photo URLs:
Missing Since:: Missing Since 09/15/2017
Missing From:: Missing From Middleton, Wisconsin
Classification:: Classification Missing
Gender:: Male
Race:: Race White
Date of Birth:: Date of Birth 09/04/1981 (43)
Age:: Age 36 years old
Height and Weight:: Height and Weight 5’7 – 5’9, 170 – 180 pounds
Clothing/Jewelry Description:
Distinguishing Characteristics:: Distinguishing Characteristics Caucasian male. Brown hair, hazel eyes. Balistreri’s nickname is Johnny. His ears are pierced. He has the following tattoos: his last name “Balistreri” in Old English script on his back, a skull with hair on the top of his right shoulder, the phrase “Smile now, cry later” with masks and stars on his left arm, a worm with a hat and eyes on his upper left arm, hearts with “Mom” and “Dad” banners and the name “Arianna” with stars on his lower left arm, and a cross on the inside of his lower right arm. Photos of some of his tattoos are posted with this case summary.
Details of Disappearance:: Michael Balistreri’s roommates in Middleton, Wisconsin, last saw him on September 15, 2017. He didn’t have a car, and nobody has heard from him since. There’s not much information known about what happened to him.
Agency:: Middleton Police Department 608-824-7300
Source Links: