Judith Ann Elwell

Case Details

Photo URLs:

PhotoPhotoPhoto

This person was missing Missing Since 07/06/1967

Missing Since:
Missing Since 07/06/1967
Missing From:
Missing From Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
Classification:
Classification Non-Family Abduction
Gender:
Female
Race:
Race White
Date of Birth:
Age:
Age 5 years old
Height and Weight:
Height and Weight Unknown
Clothing/Jewelry Description:
Clothing/Jewelry Description A blue and white striped pullover shirt, light green shorts, white socks and blue canvas sneakers.
Distinguishing Characteristics:
Distinguishing Characteristics Caucasian female. Black hair, dark brown eyes.
Details of Disappearance:
In July 1967, Judith disappeared from her Oklahoma City home. The next day, one of her shoes and a piece of rope were found nearby, suggesting a struggle. Her brother, Mark, recalled seeing a large black car near their house several times before her disappearance, even following him. He suspects the driver abducted Judith.

About a month later, five-year-old Brenda White vanished from nearby Midwest City. Her body was found months later. Both girls were around the same age, lived in similar areas, and had been warned about strangers. This led some, including a private investigator, to believe the same person may be responsible for both disappearances. The investigator thinks he knows the suspect – a man who was a teenager in 1967, lived in Harrah, Oklahoma, and later had convictions for crimes including child sexual abuse.

Unfortunately, police files for both cases are missing or destroyed, making solving these mysteries even harder. Judith’s parents are deceased, leaving her brother as her only family. Both cases remain unsolved.

Agency:
Midwest City Police Department 405-739-1317
Source Links:
READ Also  Disappearance Of Julie L. Cunningham [Update 2025]